Stocks Retake February Highs, But Are the Gains Built to Last?

Stocks have once again climbed past their February highs, signaling a resilient comeback after months of market uncertainty. Yet beneath this sharp rebound lies a more complex narrative—one shaped by uneven gains, fading strategist optimism, and cautious institutional players. As retail traders chase momentum and economic data sends mixed signals, the question arises: Is this rally the beginning of sustained growth, or a short-lived spike in a shaky market?

Stocks Retake February Highs With Caution in the Air

Stocks may have reclaimed the ground lost earlier this year, but the market mood remains far from euphoric. The S&P 500 has climbed back above its February peak, recovering nearly 20% in just four months. While that pace looks impressive on paper, investor sentiment hasn’t caught up. Unlike previous rallies, this one feels restrained, as the bulk of the gains appear concentrated in a handful of large-cap tech names. Earnings have modestly improved, and valuations have dipped slightly—from 22.5x to 22x forward earnings—but those numbers still suggest a pricey market.

Digging deeper, the equal-weighted version of the index tells a different story. It lags behind, stuck near its ten-year average, revealing that the broader market isn’t sharing equally in the rally. While corporate results have helped justify some optimism, Wall Street strategists aren’t convinced. Forecasts that once aimed for a 12% annual gain have been slashed. The current median target now sits below the actual index level—an unusual shift that reflects uncertainty beneath the surface.

Meme Stocks, IPO Mania, and Speculative Swings

Retail energy is providing the market with some juice—though it’s of the speculative variety. Meme stocks and fresh IPOs have caught fire again, with investors chasing volatile names. The VanEck Social Sentiment ETF is up 50% in just under three months, and companies like Circle Internet Group have made explosive debuts before quickly tumbling. While these moves grab headlines, they also highlight the high-risk appetite driving parts of the market.

Meanwhile, systematic funds remain largely on the sidelines, hesitant to re-enter in the face of uncertain macro signals. Broader fundamentals have improved slightly—lower oil prices, a cooling dollar, and expectations of a Fed rate cut in September—but none of these have spurred significant equity inflows. Even with a 27% rebound from April lows, investor surveys suggest skepticism still reigns. Only a small group of stocks are hitting new highs, and most S&P 500 components are still well below their own peaks.

The big question now: Is this a healthy leg of a long bull market or just a late-stage surge with limited fuel? Market history offers examples of similar rebounds, but they often ended with sharp corrections. With the Fed, earnings, and macro volatility all in play, caution is still the name of the game.

Make money without lifting your fingers: Start using a world-class auto trading solution.

EightCap, your trusted Partner in CFDs, Cryptocurrencies and Stocks.